← Data and charts
AI & evaluation · Updated 2026-11

What counts as evidence for each check, and what does not

Table 2 in “Assay: Checking AI-Written Text Against Evidence, One Question at a Time”: 10 rows, 4 columns.

Click a column heading to sort.
What counts as evidence for each check, and what does not
citationsa bibliographic record with matching authors, title and year; a registry entry for the DOI givena model's say-so; a record that matches only the titleCrossRef, OpenAlex, Open Library, PubMed (opt-in), Semantic Scholar (opt-in), the DOI registries
quotesthe sentence occurring in the supplied source texta paraphrase; a quotation under twelve charactersthe user's source text
figuresthe same value occurring in the supplied materialsthe same digits with a different unit or kind (40% against 40)the user's materials
gatea source whose domain is in the user's tier policy at the required tier, counted over distinct sitesa source's own claim about its standing; an unlisted domain above tier 3the user's policy
groundingan approved claim that exists, with a matching figurea tag that names no approved claim; reasoning ([[logic]]) offered for a numberthe user's approved claims
valuesa published series for the exact period and unita nearby year; a different unit; a model's figureWorld Bank, IMF, Eurostat and Our World in Data (opt-in), any statistics service the user describes, figures a person seeded
linksan HTTP response from the pagea blocked or unreachable response treated as absencethe live web
supporta quotation, given by a judge, that is found in the supplied sourcethe judge's verdict alonethe user's source text
retractionsa retraction, withdrawal, correction or concern notice for the DOIan absence of notice read as proof of noneCrossref, including Retraction Watch
legala decision held under the citation, with the case nameda citation not held (reported as not verified, not as invented)CourtListener
Table 2 in “Assay: Checking AI-Written Text Against Evidence, One Question at a Time”: 10 rows, 4 columns.

Cite this chart

Extrafemi Research (2026). What counts as evidence for each check, and what does not [Chart]. Data from Assay: Checking AI-Written Text Against Evidence, One Question at a Time. https://research.extrafemi.com/data/assay--data-2