| citations | a bibliographic record with matching authors, title and year; a registry entry for the DOI given | a model's say-so; a record that matches only the title | CrossRef, OpenAlex, Open Library, PubMed (opt-in), Semantic Scholar (opt-in), the DOI registries |
|---|---|---|---|
| quotes | the sentence occurring in the supplied source text | a paraphrase; a quotation under twelve characters | the user's source text |
| figures | the same value occurring in the supplied materials | the same digits with a different unit or kind (40% against 40) | the user's materials |
| gate | a source whose domain is in the user's tier policy at the required tier, counted over distinct sites | a source's own claim about its standing; an unlisted domain above tier 3 | the user's policy |
| grounding | an approved claim that exists, with a matching figure | a tag that names no approved claim; reasoning ([[logic]]) offered for a number | the user's approved claims |
| values | a published series for the exact period and unit | a nearby year; a different unit; a model's figure | World Bank, IMF, Eurostat and Our World in Data (opt-in), any statistics service the user describes, figures a person seeded |
| links | an HTTP response from the page | a blocked or unreachable response treated as absence | the live web |
| support | a quotation, given by a judge, that is found in the supplied source | the judge's verdict alone | the user's source text |
| retractions | a retraction, withdrawal, correction or concern notice for the DOI | an absence of notice read as proof of none | Crossref, including Retraction Watch |
| legal | a decision held under the citation, with the case named | a citation not held (reported as not verified, not as invented) | CourtListener |
AI & evaluation · Updated 2026-11
What counts as evidence for each check, and what does not
Table 2 in “Assay: Checking AI-Written Text Against Evidence, One Question at a Time”: 10 rows, 4 columns.
Cite this chart
Extrafemi Research (2026). What counts as evidence for each check, and what does not [Chart]. Data from Assay: Checking AI-Written Text Against Evidence, One Question at a Time. https://research.extrafemi.com/data/assay--data-2